Do day traders make money? What the studies actually show

Fewer than 1% of day traders in Taiwan reliably beat the market after fees; 97% of persistent Brazilian day traders lost money. The research, explained plainly.

In this article 6 sections

Short answer: almost none do, over any stretch long enough to matter. The best evidence comes from countries whose exchanges or regulators handed researchers complete records of every trade by every person, so nobody who quit or blew up drops out of the sample. In those records, the share of day traders who reliably beat the market, after costs, is under 1%.

That is not a forecast about you, and we don't make forecasts. It is what the data show about the people who tried before you. This guide walks through the three studies most often cited, what they measured, and where their limits are.

What share of day traders are profitable?

In the largest dataset, about 5% of those trading in a given month are ahead over their day-trading history so far, and fewer than 1% predictably beat the market after fees.

Brad Barber, Yi-Tsung Lee, Yu-Jane Liu and Terrance Odean studied every day trade on the Taiwan Stock Exchange from 1992 to 2006. Their published paper in the Journal of Financial Markets concludes that "less than 1% of the total population of day traders is able to predictably and reliably earn positive abnormal returns net of fees"1. A companion paper by the same team (with Ke Zhang) adds that the fraction of profitable day traders was "consistently about 5%"2 across 1995 to 2006, counting as profitable anyone with at least 10 days of day-trading experience and positive lifetime net day-trading profits before that month, and that day traders as a group lost money net of fees in every one of the 15 years studied.

Share of day traders who came out ahead, by study
  • Taiwan: ahead over their history so far, 10+ days (1995–2006)≈5%
  • Brazil: persisted 300+ days and made money (2013–2015 starters)≈3%
  • Taiwan: predictably beat the market after fees (1992–2006)<1%
  • Brazil: earned more than a bank teller's starting pay0.4%

Different measures from different markets and periods; read each with its definition below. Brazil's 3% is the complement of the 97% who lost money. Source: Barber, Lee, Liu & Odean: The cross-section of speculator skill: Evidence from day trading, Journal of Financial Markets 18 (2014); Barber, Lee, Liu, Odean & Zhang: Do day traders rationally learn about their ability? (working paper, Oct 2017); Chague, De-Losso & Giovannetti: Day trading for a living? (FGV EESP working paper 525, 2020)

What did the Taiwan studies find?

That a small, skilled group exists, that it is tiny, and that the losses of everyone else are large and persistent.

Taiwan is a good laboratory. Day trading made up about 20% of all trading volume there from 1995 to 2006, almost 140,000 individuals day traded in an average month, and the researchers had every trade. They ranked day traders by one year's results and tracked them the next year. The top 500 went on to earn 37.9 basis points (0.379%) a day after fees; the bottom-ranked lost 28.9 basis points a day after fees. So skill differences are real, but the group that shows persistent skill is a sliver of the population.

The second paper asked why people keep at it. Its answers are uncomfortable:

  • More than 75% of day traders quit within two years, and losers were more likely to quit than winners.
  • But many losers didn't quit. Traders with 50 or more days of experience and a record of losses had a 95.3% probability of day trading again in the next 12 months, against 96.4% for those with a record of profits.
  • Unprofitable traders accounted for 72% of day-trading volume over the sample, and about 80% in its last several years.

A broader study by the same authors in the Review of Financial Studies (2009)3 looked at all individual investors in Taiwan, not only day traders, and found their trading cost them an annual performance penalty of 3.8 percentage points, equal to 2.2% of Taiwan's GDP, while institutions gained 1.5 points a year.

What did the Brazil study find?

That among people who stuck with day trading for 300 days or more, 97% lost money.

Fernando Chague, Rodrigo De-Losso and Bruno Giovannetti, economists in São Paulo, used regulator data on every individual who began day trading Brazil's mini-Ibovespa index futures between 2013 and 2015. That was 19,646 people; according to Bloomberg's report on the paper6, 1,551 of them kept going for at least 300 trading days. Of those persistent traders, the 2020 version of the paper4 reports that 97% lost money and only 0.4% earned more than a bank teller's starting pay (about US$54 a day). The best performer averaged about US$310 a day, with a daily standard deviation of about US$2,560, so even that result came with enormous swings.

The figures differ slightly between versions: the 2019 SSRN version5 said 1.1% earned more than Brazil's minimum wage and 0.5% more than a bank teller. Either way the authors' conclusion is the same: it is "virtually impossible" for individuals to day trade for a living, and they found no evidence that traders improved with experience. Their abstract notes this is contrary to what day-trading course providers claim.

Why do most day traders lose money?

Costs, competition and leverage, in roughly that order.

  • Costs compound with frequency. Even with $0 commissions, every round trip pays the bid-ask spread, and options, futures and per-share pricing add fees (compare them in our Interactive Brokers and TradeStation reviews). The SEC notes that day traders "have high expenses, paying their firms large amounts in commissions, for training, and for computers."
  • The other side is often a professional. The Brazil authors frame it as individuals competing with high-frequency trading firms, which have faster systems and lower costs.
  • Leverage magnifies mistakes. The SEC's day-trading brochure7 notes that day traders "usually buy on borrowed money," which raises losses as much as gains. Our cash vs margin guide explains how that works.
  • Losers keep trading. The Taiwan data show unprofitable traders persisting and carrying most of the volume. A short winning streak is easy to mistake for skill.

How reliable are these studies for US traders today?

They are the best data available, but they come from other countries and earlier periods, so treat them as strong evidence, not a law.

Their strength is completeness: they include everyone, not just the survivors who post screenshots. Their limits are real too. Taiwan's data end in 2006, before $0-commission US apps; Brazil's cover one futures contract over a few years. US-wide data of the same quality haven't been published, and US costs and market structure differ. Lower commissions would help day traders at the margin, but the competition and leverage problems remain. We found no large, complete dataset showing that most retail day traders profit anywhere.

What should you do with this?

Decide before you start how much you are willing to lose learning, and treat it as a cost, not an investment.

If you still want to try, practise on a simulator first (thinkorswim's paperMoney and Webull's paperTrade are free with an account; see charting platforms), read our risk management guide for position sizing and loss limits, and know the tax treatment of short-term gains. Be wary of anyone selling a course on the back of their own results: the Brazil authors note their findings contradict what course providers claim.

Sources

  1. Barber, Lee, Liu & Odean: The cross-section of speculator skill: Evidence from day trading, Journal of Financial Markets 18 (2014) escholarship.org
  2. Barber, Lee, Liu, Odean & Zhang: Do day traders rationally learn about their ability? (working paper, Oct 2017) faculty.haas.berkeley.edu
  3. Barber, Lee, Liu & Odean: Just how much do individual investors lose by trading?, Review of Financial Studies 22(2) (2009) ideas.repec.org
  4. Chague, De-Losso & Giovannetti: Day trading for a living? (FGV EESP working paper 525, 2020) ideas.repec.org
  5. Chague, De-Losso & Giovannetti: Day trading for a living? (SSRN 3423101, 2019 version) papers.ssrn.com
  6. Bloomberg: Day traders in Brazil study would've done better with 9-to-5 job (Aug 15, 2020) bloomberg.com
  7. SEC: Day Trading: Your Dollars at Risk (Apr 2005) sec.gov

Facts last checked November 2026. Spotted something out of date? Tell us at editor@daytrade.now.

Compare every platform side by side

More guides